Insurance Benefits of SMS for Small Operators and Manufacturers

“A compliant Safety Management System (SMS) doesn’t just enhance safety—it demonstrates measurable risk reduction that insurers recognize and reward with lower premiums.”

When aviation professionals think about SMS, insurance isn’t usually the first topic that comes to mind. But for the following types of organizations, an effective SMS can be the difference between an underwriter’s hesitation and a lower premium:

• Small Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 135 charter operators;

• Sightseeing operators under 14 CFR part 91.147; and

• 14 CFR part 21 manufacturers now required to implement SMS under 14 CFR part 5.

Today’s insurers are looking beyond aircraft hull values and pilot hours to organizational maturity, safety culture, and data‑driven decision making. A functional, documented, and continuously improving SMS—aligned with part 5, International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Doc 9859, and Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Advisory Circular (AC) 120–92D—gives your organization a measurable advantage.

---

1. SMS as a Risk‑mitigation Strategy Insurers Can Quantify

A well‑implemented SMS shows your organization systematically identifies and mitigates risk before it results in a loss, something insurers translate directly into lower perceived exposure.

Underwriters routinely assess—

Factor	What They Look For
Incident & claim history	Lower frequency/severity trends with corrective actions
Maintenance quality	Documentation, repeat discrepancy rate, reliability programs
Pilot training & oversight	Recurrent training, SOPs, stabilized approach criteria adoption
Organizational responsiveness	Hazard reporting, risk assessments, timely closure of actions

An operator that can show documented hazard reports, risk assessments, and corrective actions—especially using structured methods such as the FAA’s risk matrix—demonstrates that hazards are actively managed, not ignored. That proactive mindset lowers loss potential, and insurers know it.

---

2. Alignment With Part 5 and ICAO Doc 9859 Builds Credibility

With the FAA’s SMS rule now in effect, most operators and manufacturers know SMS is no longer optional: it’s the accepted standard for demonstrating a proactive safety culture. The challenge now is designing a system that satisfies regulators and earns insurer confidence.

Aligning with part 5, ICAO Doc 9859, and AC 120–92D does more than ensure compliance: it builds credibility. These frameworks define what insurers recognize as a mature, data‑driven safety culture that continuously identifies and controls risks.

When your SMS manual cites these references and shows evidence of implementation, it signals to underwriters that your risk‑management practices are structured, traceable, and internationally validated. That confidence often translates into better bids, broader coverage options, and lower deductibles.

---

3. Demonstrated Continuous Improvement = Lower Risk Trend

Under part 5, Subpart D: Safety Assurance, organizations must evaluate the risk controls’ effectiveness and make continuous improvements. This is not just regulatory, it’s financial as well.

Insurers look for evidence you measure what matters. Meaningful Safety Performance Indicators (SPI) go beyond counting reports—they show how the organization learns from data and reduces exposure.

Objective	Measure	Target	Data Source
Reduce runway incursions and surface deviations	Number of events per 10,000 operations	50% reduction within 12 months	Event reports and FOQA data
Improve maintenance reliability	Repeat discrepancies per 100 write-ups	<2% repeat rate per quarter	Maintenance tracking system
Increase safety report quality	Reports containing complete causal factors and mitigation details	≥80% of reports meet completeness criteria	Safety reporting database
Shorten corrective-action closure time	Average days to closure	<30 days average	Audit records
Strengthen safety communication	Documented safety meetings or bulletins per quarter	≥4 per quarter	Promotion logs

These metrics emphasize effectiveness, not just activity. Tracking repeat maintenance discrepancies or corrective‑action closure time shows insurers management fixes and verifies problems. Measuring safety‑report quality demonstrates analytical maturity, not just volume.

Trend data like this predicts lower claim frequency and severity. When you can show steady improvement, you look not only compliant, but investable.

---

4. SMS Data Creates Negotiating Leverage

At renewal time, the broker’s job is easier (and your premiums often lower) if you can provide—

• A hazard reporting summary showing trends and mitigations,

• Internal audit results and corrective‑action closures,

• Management reviews demonstrating accountability, and

• Safety promotion evidence, such as training logs and newsletters.

This documentation shows your risk exposure is actively managed. For example, an operator that identified a trend in unstable approaches and introduced stabilized‑approach criteria can show reduced event frequency—a data‑driven outcome insurers can price favorably.

---

5. Manufacturers Benefit, Too

For part 21 manufacturers, the 2024 FAA SMS rule extension brings them under part 5. Although implementation may seem complex, operators that embed SMS principles into their design and production systems quickly gain both insurance and operational advantages.

Product‑liability underwriters evaluate how design and production hazards are identified, mitigated, and tracked. A manufacturer linking hazard analysis, configuration control, and supplier oversight through SMS can demonstrate traceable risk management throughout the product lifecycle, which not only supports reduced premiums, but also strengthens the company’s legal defense by proving that risk was systematically managed in accordance with international standards.

---

6. Culture and Ethics Matter to Insurers

Section 3.3 of AC 120–92D emphasizes that a safety policy should be supported by a Code of Ethics: a public statement that the organization values integrity, reporting, and continuous improvement.

From an insurer’s standpoint, that translates to cultural stability. Organizations with open reporting environments experience fewer surprises, and employees identify hazards earlier, before they lead to loss.

In practical terms: ethical transparency reduces claims.

---

7. The Return on Investment (ROI) of Safety: Tangible and Intangible

A functional SMS pays for itself in multiple ways, especially when viewed through the lens of insurance risk.

Benefit Type	How It Reduces Insurance Exposure
Direct Financial	Fewer claims and deductibles, leading to lower premiums
Operational	Fewer incidents and maintenance disruptions that drive loss ratios
Reputational	Stronger credibility with underwriters and customers
Regulatory	Compliance with part 5 and ICAO Annex 19; signals disciplined management
Cultural	Engaged employees identify hazards sooner, preventing costly events

Each of these outcomes contribute to the predictable, low‑variance risk profile underwriters reward. SMS doesn’t just improve safety—it stabilizes financial performance, which insurers directly translate into premium advantages.

---

8. What Do Insurers Actually Say? (Direct References)

Industry voices confirm the financial value of SMS:

• United States Aircraft Insurance Group (USAIG) CEO John Brogan stated underwriters increasingly assess whether a company has an SMS when evaluating risk. (AIN Online)

• ASQS GmbH notes “Insurance companies value organizations that actively manage safety…often leading to reduced insurance premiums and better coverage terms.” (asqs.net, emphasis in original)

• The Aerospace Industries Association (AIA) observed “A robust SMS…enhance[s] the perception of sound investment in flight operations…potentially leading to better coverage and lower premiums.” (AIA Safety Report)

• The National Business Aviation Association (NBAA) advises operators to review “the standard premium reductions each underwriter offers for risk mitigation tools…such as…the presence of an SMS.” (nbaa.org)

Together, these sources confirm SMS isn’t just a compliance exercise—it’s a financial signal of prudence insurers recognize and reward.

---

9. How To Get Started

For operators and manufacturers just beginning their SMS journey, start simple and scale smart:

1. Draft a safety policy that clearly states management’s commitment.

2. Identify hazards using simple risk matrices.

3. Document mitigations and responsibilities.

4. Track performance using measurable objectives.

5. Promote safety through open communication and recognition.

Then, build on that foundation using AC 120–92D as your roadmap. You don’t need complex software or large teams, just consistency, transparency, and documentation.

---

Final Thoughts

In aviation, risk can never be eliminated, but it can be managed, measured, and communicated. A functional SMS shows you’re doing exactly that.

For insurers, that means fewer unknowns. For you, it means better rates, broader coverage, and a reputation for professionalism that attracts customers, employees, and partners alike.

In the end, a robust SMS isn’t just about compliance: it’s about confidence. And confidence is currency in both safety and insurance.

Need help with SMS?

Our experts can help you create or integrate SMS into all levels your organization.

Get Expert SMS Help

Related tags: #AviationSafety, #SafetyManagementSystem, #AviationInsurance, #RiskManagement, #SMSCompliance

Any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not the opinion of PAI Consulting. In addition, this article may contain links to third-party websites. PAI Consulting does not endorse or make any representations about them, or any information, software, or other products or materials found there, or any results that may be obtained from using them.